Comprehensive Guide On Toilet Seats: All You Need to Know About Toilet Seats in 2025

When it comes to bathroom furnishing, choosing the right toilet seat is one of the most important decisions you will make. There is no denying that getting it right would transform your toileting experience, giving you exquisite comfort and adding a welcoming aesthetic to your bathroom. 

That said, a lot goes into choosing the right toilet seat. You have to get the shape, size, and materials right. You also have to look at how easy it is to install amidst a flurry of other factors. How do you balance functionality, aesthetics, durability, and cost?

Whether you're renovating your bathroom or simply replacing an old seat, we have taken the pain to curate the most extensive and comprehensive guide on the internet about toilet seats in 2025.

Do all toilet seats fit any toilet?

  • Short Answer: The quick answer is NO. Unfortunately, not all toilet seats will fit every toilet.

Let us get into the details.

As you would expect, there is a wide variety of toilets. They come in various shapes, sizes, and bolt-hole spacings. More than the more common shapes like round, elongated (oval), and D-shaped toilet seats, there are also unique or proprietary shapes (especially in older or designer toilets).

How to know if a seat would fit your toilet

Three fundamental things will tell you if a toilet seat would fit your toilet. These are the bolt-hole spacing, shape, and sometimes the peculiarity of the manufacturer's design.

  • Shape Considerations: It is non-negotiable that the length of your toilet (and of course, its curvature) aligns with the seat. A seat designed for a round bowl will be too short on an elongated bowl; an elongated seat on a round bowl will protrude awkwardly. Get it?
  • Bolt-Hole Spacing: This can be measured from the center of one bolt hole to the center of the other. This is typically 5.5 inches, although this could extend to 6 inches in some scenarios.

Note that some toilets are specialty models so this standard bolt-spacing may not apply.

Are all toilet seats a universal size?

  • Reality Check: It is so easy to read the wrong meaning to the term "universal". Most toilet seats labeled “universal” are versatile and tend to fit most standard toilets (particularly in the UK). However, they aren’t guaranteed to fit every single toilet.
  • Common Sizes:
    • Round Seats: In most cases, round toilet seats measure about 16.5 inches from the mounting holes to the front edge.
    • Elongated (Oval) Seats: This variety commonly measures around 18.5 inches.
    • D-Shaped Seats: This category tends to have a wider variety,   especially if you seek European or high-design toilets.

Key Point: Even within these shape categories, slight differences in length and width can exist. “Universal” is convenient marketing, but always verify with measurements.

Can you put any seat on a toilet?

There is no quick answer to this. A lot of this has to do with the size and shape compatibility of the seat. Also, for your seat to fit well with your toilet, the bolt-hole space must also be compatible.

We have commonly seen homeowners try to fix the wrong toilet seats on the wrong toilets. This is more common when they try to fit a round toilet bowl with an elongated seat. This would result in gaps or overhangs.

Incorrect matches -- especially in the mounting hardware -- also result in your toilet wobbling as time goes on. Of course, when your toilet seat and toilet don't align, it does not look great either.

We always recommend that you measure your hardware before making up your mind on which seat to go with. Factor in criteria like the bolt spread, width, and length. If you have a more special toilet (or say your hardware is older), we will advise you to check the manufacturer’s guidelines or consult a specialized supplier.

Is it better to have a wooden or plastic toilet seat?

For eternity, we have had people argue between wooden and plastic. "Which is better", our customers always ask us. Well, the answer depends on your situation, and of course, your lifestyle choices.

We have seen that some homeowners prefer the warm, classic feel and robust look of a wooden seat. This is particularly relevant if your bathroom is a bit chilly.

Conversely, if you want a more contemporary look, you may want to go with plastic toilet seats. More than the aesthetic, plastic toilets offer easy cleaning, moisture resistance, and affordability.

It goes without saying that both wooden and plastic toilet seats have their respective advantages and disadvantages. Let us tell you a bit of both worlds.

  • Wooden Seat Pros:
    • Warmer to the touch, especially appreciated in colder climates.
    • Has a classic, sometimes more “upscale” or traditional appearance.
    • Often feels sturdier or heavier.
  • Wooden Seat Cons:
    • Potential to warp or crack if exposed to moisture or harsh chemicals.
    • Can be prone to chipping or damage over time.
  • Plastic Seat Pros:
    • Typically more resistant to moisture, staining, and cracking (especially high-quality plastics like polypropylene).
    • Easier to clean thoroughly—less porous.
    • Often less expensive (though premium plastic seats exist).
  • Plastic Seat Cons:
    • Some feel it’s colder and less “luxurious.”
    • May feel flimsier if it’s a lower-quality plastic.

Which toilet seat material is best?

Many factors go into determining which toilet seat material suits you best. For us, the primary criteria are:

  • Best for Hygiene & Easy Maintenance: If you are keen on a toilet seat that is easier to maintain and keep clean, we recommend you go with high-quality plastic. This could be polypropylene and thermoplastic material.
  • Best for Aesthetic & Warm Feel: If you are keen on warmth, then you should go with sealed or enamel-coated wooden seats.
  • Other Considerations We Advise You Look Out For:
    • Cost vs. Durability: From our experience, top-quality wooden or plastic toilets disproportionately outlast cheaper versions of either. They can reliably last you years while the cheaper variants degrade quickly.
    • Design Preference: If you desire a greater variety of styles and decor, wooden toilet seats favor you more as they are a broad spectrum of décor styles better. On the other hand, plastic suits are more minimalist in design.
    • Comfort & Warmth: Personal preference plays a big role.

What is the most comfortable toilet seat shape?

Comfort is a big thing when choosing toilet seats. You want to "feel at home" right on your toilet seat, hence the criticality of getting the shape right.

Oval (or elongated), D-shape, and round are the three most common shapes in toilet seats. Here is what we have learned about them over the years.

  • Elongated (Oval): The extended front provides more seating space, often deemed more comfortable by taller users or adults in general.
  • Round: Can feel cramped for some, but is adequate for many people and saves space. Aside from excelling in tight spaces, round toilet seats are great for smaller bathrooms, or children’s bathrooms.
  • D-Shape: D-shaped toilets are pretty sleek and more common in European homes. They are ergonomic, giving you more comfort. However, these toilet seats tend to need more space. Also from what we have seen across the last seven years, these toilet seats are limited in variety and compatibility.
  • At the end, Comfort is Subjective: Some find that specialized contour seats or padded seats offer additional comfort, but padded seats may be less sanitary over time. The “best” shape marries functional comfort, space constraints, and personal preference.

How do I know my toilet seat size?

To choose the right seat for your toilet, you need to know your toilet size. Here is our recommended system for determining that.

  1. Bolt-Hole Distance: Center of one mounting hole to the center of the other (commonly 5.5 inches in the US).
  2. Length: Place your tape measure at the midpoint between the two bolt holes, then stretch it straight to the very front of the bowl’s rim.
  3. Width: Measure across the bowl at its widest point.

Pro Tip: Write these measurements down and keep them handy when shopping online or in-store.

How do I know if my toilet seat is top or bottom fixing?

Knowing whether your toilet seat is top-fix or bottom-fix is important in choosing the best replacement. This essentially refers to how the toilet seat is attached to the bowl.

Below are some stand-out features of top-fix seats.

  • Top-Fixing Seats:
    • The bolts are inserted from the top (above the bowl).
    • Often used where the underside of the bowl is inaccessible (e.g., back-to-wall or fully skirted toilets).
    • May have a screw that tightens the bolt into an expanding anchor plug below the ceramic.

Next, let us tell you how to identify bottom-fix toilet seats.

  • Bottom-Fixing Seats:
    • Traditional approach: a bolt goes through the hole, and a nut is tightened underneath.
    • Most older or open-access toilets use this system.

What if you can't still tell what fix your toilet seat is? Well, we have some handy clues that can yet help you.

  • Identifying Clues:
    • If you see no way to reach the underside of the toilet, it’s likely a top-fix.
    • If you can easily access nuts underneath, it’s bottom-fix.

How do I fit a new toilet seat?

Plumbers in the UK typically charge £40-£60 for an hour of toilet installation. Getting your new toilet seat fitted can cost you anywhere from £30 to as much as £200.

But you can do it yourself if you fancy. Below is a step-by-step process to remove your old toilet seat and fit your new one.

  1. Remove Old Seat:
    • Lift bolt caps (if present).
    • Unscrew or loosen the nuts underneath.
    • If stuck, use penetrating oil or carefully cut through rusted bolts.
  2. Clean the Rim:
    • Clear away debris or mineral buildup.
    • Sanitize the area where the new seat will rest.
  3. Align New Seat:
    • Position the seat hinges over the toilet’s mounting holes.
    • Ensure it’s centered (left-right) and flush with the rim.
  4. Insert Bolts:
    • Depending on top-fixing or bottom-fixing, place the bolts accordingly.
  5. Tighten Bolts/Nuts:
    • Use a screwdriver or wrench.
    • Don’t overtighten or you risk cracking plastic parts or the ceramic bowl.
  6. Check Alignment:
    • Open and close the seat to ensure it doesn’t shift.

Pro Tip: If available, use rubber grommets or washers to minimize seat movement and avoid scratching the bowl.

What is normal toilet seat height?

It depends on what you want. We recommend:

  • Standard Height: ~15 inches from the floor to the top of the seat. This is more prevalent in older or basic toilets.
  • Comfort/ADA Height: If you are taller (or for those with mobility issues, you could go with 17-19 inches from the floor. This is more comfortable with less need for bending.

Inevitably, the height of your toilet seat greatly affects your posture when pooping. When you use a stool, for example, you would go with a slightly squatted posture. This could help straighten the anorectal angle, aiding in easier bowel movements.

What is the difference between a toilet seat and a commode?

Toilet seats are different from commodes, however interchangeable both names could appear. Starting with a toilet seat is traditionally a hinged seat (and lid) that attaches to a traditional toilet bowl.

The commode is way different. Historically, commodes have been a piece of furniture containing a chamber pot. These days, they are more commonly referred to as portable toilets.

These are more prevalent in healthcare settings and preferred for ease of use as they can be readily placed near a bed or in smaller spaces.

What to look out for when buying a toilet seat?

After 25 years of selling toilet seats, here is what we would do when buying a toilet:

  1. Shape & Size: Confirm it matches your toilet bowl measurements.
  2. Material: Plastic (various grades) vs. wood (various finishes).
  3. Hinge Quality: Look for corrosion-resistant hinges (metal or sturdy plastic) and consider soft-close or quick-release features.
  4. Style & Color: Match your bathroom decor. White is the most common, but many seats come in off-white, biscuit, black, or wood finishes.
  5. Special Features:
    • Soft-close (no slam).
    • Quick-release hinges for easy cleaning.
    • Integrated child seat or bidet functionality.
    • Heated seats (more high-tech).
  6. Brand Reputation & Warranty: A seat from a reputable brand might cost more but can offer better longevity.

How much should you spend on a toilet seat?

There is no definitive answer to this, as a lot depends on your budget, aesthetic preferences, and functional needs. But here is an estimate of what you should be spending

  • Budget Options (£7–£16): If you want something basic and ready to go, you could spend anywhere from £7 to £16. This will easily get you a basic plastic or economy wooden seats. They’ll do the job but may wear out faster.
  • Mid-Range (£16–£38): These are superior in quality to the previous option. This budget range typically offers soft-close hinges, better plastic quality, or well-finished wood.
  • High-End (£40–£130+): Here is the premium class. Parting with something as pricey as this would get you a toilet seat made from premium materials (hardwood, high-grade plastics), designer brands, or advanced features (heated seat, built-in bidet).
  • Ultra-Luxury (Up to £450+): This is for the big players. You want class if you are spending up to £400 on your toilet seat. You would readily get a luxurious toilet seat with this. Picture smart toilet seats with integrated bidet wash, warm-air dryer, night light, deodorizer, etc.
  • Recommendation: Consider how much you value comfort, special features, and durability versus a simple replacement.

How often should you change your toilet seat?

On average, if you have maintained your toilet seat properly and the quality is good, you should replace it every 5 to 7 years.

But of course, some signs can tell you your toilet set is due for replacement way sooner:

  • Visible cracks, chips, peeling paint/coating.
  • Loose or broken hinges that can’t be easily repaired.
  • Permanent discoloration or deep stains.
  • Hygienic concerns (odor trapped in materials).
  • We always recommend that you be proactive. Unless you are going for premium toilet seats north of £100, a toilet seat is relatively inexpensive compared to the comfort and cleanliness it provides—changing it before it’s completely worn can be beneficial.

How often should you change your toilet seat?

Cleaning a toilet seat is no one's favourite chore. Unfortunately, cleaning your toilet seat is core to it being properly maintained.

Good news is that the process is not that hard. Here is how to easily clean your toilet seat:

  1. Regular Wiping: Use a soft cloth or non-abrasive sponge with mild soapy water or a gentle bathroom cleaner.
  2. Avoid Harsh Chemicals: High concentrations of bleach or abrasive powders can degrade finishes or cause discoloration, especially on wood or certain plastics.
  3. Focus on Hinges: Bacteria can accumulate where the seat connects to the bowl. A small brush or cotton swab helps.
  4. Dry Thoroughly: After cleaning, wipe with a dry cloth to avoid water spots or moisture buildup that can lead to mold.
  5. Frequency: Wipe down at least weekly—or more often if it’s a high-traffic bathroom.

Can a toilet seat be repaired?

As one of the UK's interior furnishing suppliers, a lot of customers ask us if they really need to get a new toilet seat replacement. "Eh, can't you repair it?"

It depends. If your toilet seat has only minor issues (like loose hinges), of course, that can be readily fixed. Tightening or replacing hinge bolts is common.

But there are some instances where you are simply better off getting a new replacement rather than attempting a repair:

  • Cracks in Wood or Plastic: Often difficult to repair permanently or safely. If the seat is cracked, replacing it is usually the best route for both hygiene and safety.

Hinge Replacement: Some brands sell hinge replacement kits. Ensure compatibility with your seat’s brand and model.

Can you use Harpic on a toilet seat?

Harpic is one of the most commonly used toilet cleaning solutions. But we always advise caution when using Harpic on your toilet seat.

This is because Harpic (and similar strong toilet cleaners) are formulated for the toilet bowl interior, which is ceramic/enamel.

Using Harpic directly on your toilet seats can discolor or weaken the finish on plastic or wood seats if not used properly.

So what do we recommend?

  • Use a mild cleaning solution for the seat.
  • If you must use a stronger cleaner, dilute it, apply briefly, then rinse thoroughly.

Can you use a different brand of toilet seat on a toilet?

Well, we would say yes, in most cases. More importantly, mix-and-match is fine as long as the shape, size, and bolt spacing match.

In our experience, the exception is that a number of high-end or non-standard toilets (especially European designs or wall-mounted units) may require brand-specific seats.

The safer approach would be sparing the time to verify measurements or look for compatibility notes in the product listing.

What are the toilet seat rules? How do potty seats work?

There are etiquettes for every aspect of our lives, and toilet seat usage is no different. As a gentleman or lady, here is how you should properly use a toilet seat.

  • Lower the seat and lid after use to reduce germ spread when flushing.
  • Wipe down if any spills occur.

Also, here is a dignified way to use a potty seat if you fancy:

  • A child-size seat that sits atop the adult toilet seat or replaces the seat entirely with a built-in smaller ring.
  • Keeps toddlers from slipping in and helps them feel more secure during potty training.

What is the extra toilet seat for?

  • Double-Decker Seats: Some families install a 2-in-1 seat (an adult seat plus a child seat that flips down from inside the lid).
  • Bidet Attachments: You might see an extra “layer” for water nozzles or controls.
  • Commercial or Public Restrooms: Occasionally have a split seat design, but that’s typically for hygiene and cleaning ease.

How do soft-close toilet seats work?

  • Hinge Mechanics:
    • Feature dampers (like small hydraulic cylinders or friction-based mechanisms) that slow the descent.
    • When you tap the seat or lid downward, it gradually closes instead of slamming.
  • Benefits:
    • Reduced noise.
    • Less wear on hinges and the toilet bowl rim.
    • Safer for children (prevents pinched fingers).

Which toilet style is best?

This is another debate worth settling. Commonly, homeowners and contractors are split across the options of two-piece toilets and one-piece toilets.

Let us talk a bit about them.

  • One-Piece vs. Two-Piece Toilets:
    • One-Piece: Tank and bowl fused together—fewer crevices, often more expensive.
    • Two-Piece: Separate tank and bowl—easier to move/install, more common, typically less costly.
  • Bowl Shape: Round vs. Elongated vs. D-Shaped.
  • Flushing Technology: Gravity-fed, pressure-assisted, dual-flush.
  • Design Preference: Some prefer sleek, low-profile designs; others prioritize ease of repair or cost.

Best is Subjective: Depends on budget, bathroom size, aesthetics, and comfort needs.

Our Final Words of Advice

A toilet seat may seem like a small detail in a bathroom, but choosing the right one can dramatically impact daily comfort, hygiene, and even décor. By:

  1. Measuring accurately,
  2. Understanding shape/size/material differences,
  3. Evaluating desired features, and
  4. Properly installing and maintaining it,

You ensure a pleasant, long-lasting experience. If you have an older or specially designed toilet, it is worth sparing time for due diligence and thoroughly researching your options to ensure it is compatible.

And remember: cleaning and occasional tightening of hinges will keep your seat hygienic and wobble-free for years.

With the information provided, you can confidently navigate the world of toilet seats—buying, installing, and caring for them like a pro!

Enjoy the comfort and convenience a well-chosen seat brings to your daily routine.

Shop
0 Wishlist
0 items Cart
My account